Blog

Three years later, our students are honoring those we lost

Rabbi Jason Rubenstein on how Harvard’s Jewish students marked October 7th this year.

Dear beloved fellow members of Harvard’s Jewish community,

In our students’ lives, the day whose shared ‘before’ is very different than the collective ‘after’ – is October 7, 2023 (for my generation, 9/11 is added to that list; for my parents’ generation, JFK’s assassination as well). For those who were murdered that day, there was no ‘after’ – for their families and friends, 10/7 divides a past of closeness from a present and future of loss and grief. No one in our community is more than two degrees removed from the twelve hundred lives cut short – and we are all, together, finding our way through a world that is still being re-shaped by the day’s ongoing aftermath: for Israel and Israelis, for Jews in America and across the world, including a reshaping of American politics and geo-politics.

October 7 memorial gathering at Harvard, October 2026

Here at Harvard, the questions of post-10/7 memory and politics, sympathy and exclusion, even courage and truth – are heightened in their intensity because of the intense conflict and scrutiny that began on the afternoon of October 7 itself and continue in court rooms to this day. But federal courts are not the only place where the character and future of Harvard are being adjudicated – and perhaps not even the most important. Each day, and each year, hearts and minds are being formed throughout this campus, within the Jewish community and beyond – and our most sacred responsibility is to nurture the development of wise, empathic, committed, and fearless young people who will dedicate themselves to leading our community through whatever we may face in the next two generations.

And so, the first thing I want you to see – from these photographs from Wednesday night – is that the memory of 10/7 and the solidarity that binds us together across time and space are growing despite the passage of time. Hundreds of students and faculty members, from Hillel, Chabad, and beyond, gathered – to give voice to their shared grief and unyielding determination, to cry, and to sing. Israeli students recounted the lives and never-to-be-realized promise of their beloved, murdered friends. Jewish faculty, whom we are supporting in the early stages of organizing themselves as Jewish faculty, hosted a speaker and wide-ranging discussion on understanding, and understanding how to effectively counter, the ascendance of anti-Zionism in the humanities and social sciences.

October 7 memorial gathering at Harvard, October 2026

What I wish you could see – but no photograph can capture – is students’ dedication to these efforts. Amidst the competition of classes and pre-professional opportunities, so many students chose to give their time and energy to organizing, planning, and leading this event – not merely as a vigil, but as a focal point for representing our community, from here in Cambridge to Israel and back again – to ourselves and to the rest of Harvard, many of whom are forming impressions of Judaism that will last them a lifetime.

Our community has much to grieve about the recent past, and much to fear about what is to come. Through it all, like the calm at the eye of the storm, I hope you will also know that Harvard’s Jewish community, and Harvard’s Jewish students, are neither cowering from nor cowed by hate; we are not reacting to others’ portrayals of us or wondering whether we will be safe or accepted. Our students, our faculty, and our staff are, with principle, creativity, and strength, giving voice, in public, to who they are and what they believe.

There is no balm for our grief; we cannot bring back those we have lost or unsee what we have seen. But if there is any possibility of living the hope, “may their memories be for a blessing,” “yehi zichram baruch” – our community is doing everything we can to honor their lives, never forget their deaths, and to live with a strength steeled by our commitment to one another, to those we lost on 10/7, and to those who will come after us.

With gratitude, Rabbi Jason Rubenstein, Executive Director